Time for griping
Nov. 28th, 2023 07:02 pmI also face a lot of negativity directed at at least two other characters I'm more fond of- Alistair and Cullen. If I'm not catching anti-Anders toxicity from the wider fandom, I'm witness to people shitting on those two purely on the basis of them being popular (or, in Cullen's case, because he was a templar that exemplified the hatred against mages). I've had people who claim to love Alistair happily treating him like garbage because he's positioned as opposing Anora, or even because in order to keep him in your party through to the end, you have to slaughter Loghain- another particular favorite of people I've connected with in the fandom.
There is not a single character in the series that doesn't have flaws, and some of them are more pressing than others. The problem with flawed characters is that people seem to have gone fully Purity Culture in just about every fandom, and Dragon Age is no exception. It's become a case of pitting one character's flaws against the strengths of someone else's favorite, and instead of recognizing that people attach to characters for a good personal reason folks have decided to ascribe whole negative personality traits to people over which characters they favor. It's become a case of "I feel insecure about something, and my only way to treat that is by convincing myself that someone is worse than I am".
I get a lot of Cullen-hate in my social media experience because I tend to connect with other fans of Anders, who is actually very naturally at odds with the likes of Cullen; Cullen was deeply traumatized by his experiences at the hands of blood mages, and was in an environment that fostered and festered that wound into malicious hatred. He said and did awful things. But he does, eventually, work his way out of the depths of that hatred, even if it's still a work in progress by the next game.
I don't begrudge anyone who doesn't like him as a character, for those reasons and (circling back to what I said before) because everyone has their reasons for who they like or don't like in any fictional media. And I don't even necessarily mind him catching criticism for it. But I'm very tired of the same people who defend Anders over his flaws turn around and make Cullen out to be an inhuman monster, to dismiss the very real reasons he HAS such a strong reaction to mages, to unleash all their vitriol on him as if he single-handedly invented the Circles and was solely a case for harm to others instead of a complicated, traumatized character.
And all of this? Honestly stems from the developers being inconsistent, constantly retconny, and very quick to jump on the "demonize a character to be hip with the kids" train, stirring up within the fandom that it's acceptable behavior. It stems from the top, and the end result is definitely a lot of emotional damage and isolation in a space that should be reserved for connection and healthy discussion.
Ah, but the internet doesn't do that anymore, huh? Ah well.